The Leaf in the Dark

About This Episode​

I was thinking about leaves.

Which is probably not where you expected a marketing article to begin.

Picture a leaf in daylight. You can see its color, veins, shape, and imperfections.

Now look at that same leaf at night.

Same leaf. Same tree. Same observer.

But the information available to you has changed.

The leaf didn’t suddenly become something else. The conditions under which you’re interpreting it have changed.

And that got me thinking about marketing.

We tend to imagine communication as a fairly tidy exchange.

We make something.
We send it.
Someone receives it.

Except there’s an enormous amount happening between sending and receiving.

Context.

Think about a proposal arriving in someone’s inbox at 10:15 on a calm Tuesday morning.

Now imagine that exact proposal being opened at 4:47 on Friday afternoon after a day of budget problems, unhappy customers and 73 unread emails.

Nothing inside the proposal changed.

But I don’t think we can reasonably say the experience of receiving it is identical.

The same happens with price.

A $5,000 solution can feel expensive when someone doesn’t fully understand the problem.

The exact same $5,000 can feel remarkably reasonable once they realize the problem is costing them $20,000.

Or social media.

We publish something useful and thoughtful. It performs badly.

Our immediate conclusion?

Apparently, nobody wants this.

Maybe.

Or maybe something else had everyone’s attention that day.

Maybe we caught them at the wrong moment.

Maybe they had already heard from us six times that week.

Maybe we’re asking for a complicated decision in an environment designed for casual scrolling.

None of this means the message doesn’t matter.

It matters enormously.

But the message never arrives alone.

It arrives surrounded by timing, trust, familiarity, attention, stress, previous experiences, and whatever happened to that person five minutes before they encountered us.

There’s a dangerous interpretation of this idea too.

If context influences perception, marketers might conclude that our job is to manipulate the environment until people see what we want them to see.

That’s not where I’m going.

We don’t need to manufacture fear or urgency.

We need to acknowledge that context exists.

So before automatically rewriting the headline, changing the creative, or discounting the price, maybe we should ask a few different questions.

When is someone encountering this?

What do they already know?

What are they worried about?

What decision are we asking them to make?

What happened upstream?

What information might still be missing?

Sometimes the thing in front of us genuinely needs fixing.

Sometimes we just need to look at it in a different light.

That’s the first strange lesson from an ordinary thing.

Something can remain exactly what it is and still be experienced differently.

So before you rebuild, rewrite, or rebrand the thing that isn’t working, ask yourself:

What might be changing the light around your message?

---

Listen & Share

🎧 Listen on Apple Podcasts
🎧 Listen on Spotify
▶️ Watch on YouTube